ホーム / ShortFlingブログ / Writing
この記事は現在、英語版のみ提供しています。英語版を読む →
WritingAI Rules on Fiction Platforms Compared (2026)
One question, five different answers
If you write fiction with an AI tool anywhere in the process, a lot of people ask the same practical question: where am I actually allowed to post this? The honest answer is that every platform draws the line in a different place, and the lines moved a lot between late 2025 and mid-2026.
This post compares five places as of October 2026: a Japanese web-novel platform that runs contests, an ebook distributor, a serial-fiction site, the largest fanfiction archive, and ShortFling. We only describe rules we could read in the platforms’ own pages or in reporting about them; the sources are listed at the end. Amazon’s KDP rules have their own post, KDP’s AI disclosure explained, so they are left out here.
AlphaPolis: contests and book deals exclude AI-generated work
AlphaPolis, a Japanese platform that turns web novels into books and manga, updated its contest rules on November 18, 2025 to exclude AI-generated works. According to Automaton, the change caught the winner of its 18th Fantasy Novel Awards, an isekai novel that took both the Grand Prize and the Reader’s Choice award. After the work was found to be predominantly AI-generated, the planned print edition and manga adaptation were cancelled. Automaton reported in January 2026 that the novel was still listed as a winner and still readable on the site.
The interesting detail is what AlphaPolis did not ban. Automaton notes that the company launched its own AI proofreading tool for typos and misused idioms in September 2025. The line it drew is about text that a model writes, not about assistance in general. For writers, that means a story can stay on the site while being shut out of the contests and publishing deals that are the main reason many people post there.
Draft2Digital: no fully AI-generated books
Draft2Digital, the ebook and print distributor, puts its position in its content guidelines: it is “not a destination” for mass-production book farms or for people who want to publish “100% AI-generated books,” along with low-content and summary books.
The rule is backed by money as well as wording. On April 15, 2026, D2D announced a one-time $20 activation fee for new accounts that turn on distribution, plus a $12 annual fee that is waived for accounts earning at least $100 in net royalties over the previous 12 months. According to the Alliance of Independent Authors, D2D linked the change to a flood of spam, scams and AI-generated material from automated accounts, and in some months rejected more than 70% of submitted titles. In short, AI-assisted fiction is not named as a problem; unedited machine output is.
Royal Road: allowed, but tagged
Royal Road published its AI-text policy on June 21, 2023 and has since added updates to it. It splits AI use into three levels. Grammar-checker style suggestions that keep your voice need no tag at all. If you use an AI to rewrite your own paragraphs heavily, for example as a sentence-by-sentence proofreader, the story should carry the “AI-Assisted” tag. If the AI writes the text and you direct and edit it, the story must be tagged “AI-Generated,” and the author is expected to refine the output for quality and continuity.
Two more details matter for serial writers. Behind-the-scenes help such as brainstorming and research does not need to be disclosed. And comments, reviews and forum posts may not contain AI-generated text except as a quote. The policy openly says the site cannot reliably detect AI writing, which is why it relies on tags instead of bans.
AO3: allowed, with optional tags
Archive of Our Own sits at the most permissive end. In a May 2023 statement, the Organization for Transformative Works said nothing in AO3’s Terms of Service prohibits fanworks fully or partly generated with AI, as long as they otherwise qualify as fanworks, though mass posting can still break its anti-spam rules. Its Terms of Service FAQ separately forbids scraping AO3 to collect material for commercial generative AI.
Disclosure on AO3 is voluntary. Writers can use tags such as “Created Using Generative AI,” and according to IBTimes, the OTW said in June 2026 that AI works remain allowed because a ban would be hard to enforce and could expose suspected writers to abuse. We cover the fanfiction side in more detail in Does AO3 allow AI-generated fanfiction?
What the pattern means for writers
Read side by side, the rules share one shape. Nobody on this list bans spellcheck-level help, and Royal Road openly admits it cannot reliably detect AI text, so the rules lean on disclosure and on the author’s own declaration. Where they differ is the stakes: AO3 asks you to tag if you choose to, Royal Road requires a tag, and AlphaPolis and Draft2Digital close the door to prizes or retail distribution for work that is predominantly (AlphaPolis) or entirely (Draft2Digital) machine-written.
That gives a simple working rule. Keep track of what the AI actually did in each chapter: brainstorming, line edits, or drafted prose. That record is what every one of these policies asks about, and it is also your best defence if someone accuses you of passing off machine text as your own. If you plan to sell the same story elsewhere later, write to the strictest rule you might need, not the loosest one.
Where ShortFling fits
ShortFling is an original-fiction platform, not a fanfiction archive or a chat app, and it is built around AI-assisted writing. The editor in /write helps you outline, draft and revise, and it is free within a daily allowance. Before you can publish, you sign a short creator agreement confirming that the work is your own original work, that you hold the rights to publish it, that every character is an adult and the story is fictional, and that it contains no non-consensual sexual content about any real, identifiable person.
Pressing publish submits the story for review, and it only goes public after approval. ShortFling does not currently ask for a separate AI tag, since the editor is part of the product; the review checks originality, rights and content rules instead. Finished stories land in the fiction library, which has SFW and NSFW sections, with the NSFW side behind an 18+ confirmation and availability that varies by region and platform. If you write adult fiction and are weighing other homes for it, see where to publish erotica online and does Wattpad allow NSFW.
Platform rules change often, so check each site’s current terms before you post. This is an overview, not legal advice.
FAQ
Can I post AI-assisted fiction on Royal Road?
Yes. Under Royal Road’s AI-text policy, light grammar-style help needs no tag, heavy AI rewriting of your own text should be tagged AI-Assisted, and text the AI wrote must be tagged AI-Generated and edited by you for quality.
Does Draft2Digital accept AI-assisted books?
Its content guidelines say it is not a destination for 100% AI-generated books, low-content books or summary books. They do not single out AI-assisted writing that you have substantially written and edited yourself.
Do I have to tag AI use on AO3?
No. AO3 allows works fully or partly generated with AI if they otherwise qualify as fanworks, and AI tags are optional. Mass posting can still violate its anti-spam rules.
Does ShortFling allow AI-assisted stories?
Yes. ShortFling has a built-in AI editor, and published stories must be your original work with adult, fictional characters. Publishing submits the story for review, and it goes public only after approval.
Sources
- Automaton: AlphaPolis cancels book and manga for AI-generated contest winner; rules updated Nov 18, 2025 (Jan 2026) (checked 2026-10)
- Draft2Digital content guidelines: not a destination for 100% AI-generated books (checked 2026-10)
- Alliance of Independent Authors: Draft2Digital’s April 2026 fees and the spam and AI rationale (checked 2026-10)
- Royal Road: AI-text policy (AI-Assisted and AI-Generated tags) (checked 2026-10)
- Organization for Transformative Works: AI and data scraping on the Archive (May 2023) (checked 2026-10)
- AO3 Terms of Service FAQ: scraping for commercial generative AI is forbidden (checked 2026-10)
- IBTimes UK: OTW’s June 2026 position that AI works remain allowed on AO3 (checked 2026-10)




