本指南目前僅提供英文版。閱讀英文版 →

比較

Kindroid vs Nomi vs Replika: which AI companion fits you?

All three promise an AI companion who remembers you, sends selfies and talks back out loud. The differences are in the details: how much of the memory you can see and edit, what you have to pay before the good parts unlock, how each one treats adult conversation, and what happens to your chats. Here is what their own terms, help pages and privacy policies say.

作者:ShortFling Editorial · Editorial team · 最後核實:2026-10-08

重點摘要

  • Kindroid gives you the most hands-on control: a written personality, key memories, keyword-triggered journal entries and editable “Learned Context”, with deeper memory on paid tiers.
  • Nomi leans on memory the companion manages itself (short, medium and long term, plus an “Identity Core”), shaped by optional Shared Notes; it is free to start, with paid upgrades.
  • Replika is the best-known name; its paid tiers (Pro, Ultra, Platinum) unlock relationship status, voice, selfies and saving messages to memory.
  • All three are 18+ under their own terms. Kindroid explicitly allows NSFW roleplay between adults; Nomi describes its chats as unfiltered; Replika restricted erotic roleplay in 2023.
  • None of them is end-to-end encrypted or a story you can read. If you want a finished romance rather than an ongoing chat, a story platform is a different kind of product.

The short answer

Pick Kindroid if you want to engineer your companion — write its personality, see what it remembers and fix what it gets wrong. Pick Nomi if you would rather let the companion develop on its own and nudge it now and then. Pick Replika if you want a polished, everyday companion and are comfortable with a more conservative stance on adult content.

Not sure an AI companion is what you are after at all? Our explainer on AI boyfriend apps versus story romance walks through the three kinds of “AI partner” experiences and who each one suits.

Kindroid: a companion you configure

Kindroid describes its memory as five systems in three groups: persistent (backstory, key memories, example messages, directives, Learned Context and chat history), cascaded medium-term memory, and retrievable long-term memory plus journal entries.[1]

  • The personality field (formerly called Backstory) holds up to 2,000 characters, or 2,500 for subscribers, and is the main place to define how the Kindroid speaks and relates to you.[7]
  • Journal entries are recalled when you type one of their keyphrases; each entry can have up to eight keyphrases, and how many entries can be recalled per message rises with the subscription tier.[1]
  • Learned Context, a paid feature, tracks growth and relationship, important facts and ongoing threads; you can view and edit it, and turn it off.[1]
  • You can open a reply and see which long-term memories and journal entries were recalled for it, and deprioritize ones that are not helpful.[1]

Voice and images are extensive on paid plans: subscriber benefits include voice and video calls, custom voices, selfies, video selfies and group selfies, and video avatars. Voice use is metered in monthly audio credits, and you can design a custom voice from a text description or from samples you own the rights to.[2][6]

Nomi: a companion that shapes itself

Nomi says its companions have short-, medium- and long-term memory, and in December 2024 it added an “Identity Core” in which each Nomi decides for itself which facts, preferences, behaviors and feedback are central to who it is and to your relationship.[8][10]

  • You pick a relationship type, name, base personality traits, interests and look when you create a Nomi; the traits cannot be changed later, but you can reshape them through Shared Notes, of which the Backstory is the most important.[9]
  • Nomi does not offer re-rolling or editing replies; instead it recommends out-of-character “(OOC:)” messages to correct the companion.[9]
  • In-chat selfies show what your Nomi is wearing and doing in the moment; a separate art tool generates images from prompts.[9]
  • Voice messages and calls are available, and Nomi’s 2024 beginner’s guide says voice chat requires a paid subscription and can use in-house voices or a connected ElevenLabs account.[8][9]
  • Group chats let several Nomis talk together; the 2024 guide put the limit at six per group.[9]

Replika: the best-known companion, rebuilt

Replika says it built the first AI companion ten years ago and has now rebuilt the app from the ground up. Its homepage promotes a companion that remembers your people, routines and plans, plus appearance customization, calls and selfies.[13]

  • Its terms list four programs: Free Use (limited access), Replika Pro (relationship status, premium activities, selfies, image generation, voice messages, background calls, premium voices), Replika Ultra (adds smarter conversations, self-reflections and saving messages to memory) and Replika Platinum (adds real-time video recognition, a training mode and selfie videos).[14]
  • The terms prohibit configuring a companion to simulate a specific real person without that person’s explicit written consent.[14]

Side-by-side comparison

Checked October 8, 2026 — payment model only; check each service for current prices and features
KindroidNomiReplika
Personality setupWritten personality, directives, example messages, key memoriesTraits chosen at creation, then Shared Notes (incl. Backstory)Customizable companion; relationship status on paid tiers
Memory you can seeLearned Context and journal are editable; recalled memories shown per replyMostly self-managed (Identity Core); Shared Notes are yours to editPaid Ultra tier adds “save messages to memory”
VoiceVoice messages, voice and video calls; custom voices (paid)Voice messages and calls; paid subscription per 2024 guideVoice messages and background calls (Pro)
ImagesSelfies, video selfies, group selfies, video avatarsIn-chat selfies plus prompt-based artSelfies and image generation (Pro); selfie videos (Platinum)
Payment modelOne-time free preview, trial, then subscription with Ultra/MAX add-onsFree to start; paid upgrades and credit add-onsLimited free use; Pro, Ultra and Platinum subscriptions
Adult contentNSFW roleplay between adults explicitly allowedDescribes chats as unfiltered and uncensoredErotic roleplay restricted since 2023 (pre-Feb-2023 accounts could opt back in)
Age rule18+; billing or third-party age check if flagged18+; age collected at sign-up18+
Best forTinkerers who want control over memoryPeople who want a companion that grows on its ownEveryday emotional companionship

Adult content and age rules

All three set 18 as the minimum age. How they enforce it, and what they allow once you are in, differs.[4][11][14]

  • Kindroid’s moderation guidelines say it does not filter the AI itself and lists NSFW and erotic roleplay among explicitly allowed activities. Its account-level enforcement targets three red lines: imminent self-harm planning, real-world harm to others, and sexual or abusive content involving minors — a zero-tolerance rule that a stated “18+” label does not override.[3]
  • Kindroid treats an active paid subscription as age verification. Unverified free accounts can be flagged by a behavioral age-estimation system and must then subscribe or verify through the third-party provider Yoti.[4]
  • Nomi’s homepage says the service is built on freedom of expression and describes its chats as unfiltered and uncensored. Its terms say anyone under 18 cannot use it under any circumstances, require users to provide their age, and reserve the right to add age-verification measures.[8][11]
  • Replika changed its filters in February 2023 so companions stopped engaging in erotic roleplay; after user outcry, accounts created before February 1, 2023 were offered the option to return to the earlier version.[16]
  • Replika’s current terms say users under 18 are not authorized to use the service, and they bar uploading content that is obscene or pornographic.[14]

These are each company’s stated rules as of October 2026. Content policies in this category change often — read the current terms before you invest time or money.

Privacy: what each policy says

  • Kindroid encrypts chats at rest and in transit but says it is not end-to-end encrypted, because its systems must process chats to reply and to run automated safety checks. It decrypts content for human review only when flagged, when you ask (for example in an appeal) or when legally required.[5]
  • Kindroid keeps chats and generated media until you delete that AI or your account, and says it does not sell or share personal data.[5]
  • Nomi asks you to sign up with a Google or Apple account, encourages you not to put identifying details in chats, and says it does not and will not sell or rent your personal information.[12]
  • Deleting a Nomi account removes your personal information within about 28 days, while information in its training archives would no longer be attributable to you.[12]
  • Replika says it does not use conversation content for marketing or advertising, that the third-party language-model providers it uses are contractually barred from training on your data, and that small anonymized portions of messages may be used to train its own safety systems.[15]

Which one fits you

  • You want to control the details and see what your companion remembers: Kindroid.
  • You want a companion that develops its own sense of self with light guidance from you: Nomi.
  • You want a well-known, everyday companion and do not need adult roleplay: Replika.
  • You want a romance with a beginning, a middle and an ending you do not have to prompt: none of the three — see below.

Your choice: where ShortFling fits

ShortFling is not an AI companion or AI chat app, and it is not trying to be one — there is no AI partner to talk to. It is a story platform: ShortFling Fiction offers romance novels and reader-written stories in separate SFW and NSFW zones, and the NSFW zone asks you to confirm you are 18+. Every character there is an adult. If you would rather write than read, the AI-assisted editor helps you go from outline to finished draft. Vertical short dramas are in production; their pages show “coming soon” for now. AI Star Mode is not live either — there is a waitlist. The site is available in six interface languages.

常見問題

Which has the best memory: Kindroid, Nomi or Replika?

They take different approaches. Kindroid exposes the most controls — a written personality, key memories, keyword-triggered journal entries and editable Learned Context, with more memory on higher tiers. Nomi relies on memory the companion manages itself, including its Identity Core. Replika says its companion remembers your people, routines and plans, and its Ultra tier adds saving messages to memory.

Do Kindroid, Nomi and Replika allow NSFW chat?

Kindroid’s moderation guidelines explicitly allow NSFW and erotic roleplay between adults. Nomi describes its chats as unfiltered and uncensored. Replika restricted erotic roleplay in February 2023, later letting accounts created before February 1, 2023 opt back into the earlier version. All three require users to be 18 or older.

Are Kindroid, Nomi and Replika free?

Each has a free way in, but the main features are paid. Kindroid gives new accounts a one-time preview, then requires a trial or subscription to keep chatting. Nomi is free to start with paid upgrades. Replika offers limited free use alongside Pro, Ultra and Platinum subscriptions.

Are my chats private?

None of the three describes end-to-end encryption. Kindroid encrypts chats at rest and in transit but processes them to generate replies and for safety checks. Nomi and Replika both say they do not sell your personal information. Avoid sharing identifying details in any companion chat.

Is ShortFling an AI companion app?

No. ShortFling has no AI chat partner. It is a platform for romance fiction with an 18+ NSFW zone and an AI-assisted writing editor; vertical short dramas are in production and not yet playable.

資料來源

  1. [1] Kindroid Help Center — Memory (官方)
  2. [2] Kindroid Help Center — Subscriptions (官方)
  3. [3] Kindroid Help Center — Moderation Guidelines (官方)
  4. [4] Kindroid Help Center — Age Verification (官方)
  5. [5] Kindroid — Legal (Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, effective Oct 6, 2026) (官方)
  6. [6] Kindroid Help Center — Voice, calls, and video calls (官方)
  7. [7] Kindroid Help Center — Customizing personality (官方)
  8. [8] Nomi.ai — homepage (官方)
  9. [9] Nomi.ai — Nomi 101: A Beginner’s Guide (May 13, 2024) (官方)
  10. [10] Nomi.ai — Introducing the Nomi Identity Core (官方)
  11. [11] Nomi.ai Terms of Service (effective Jan 16, 2026) (官方)
  12. [12] Nomi.ai Privacy Policy (last updated Apr 27, 2026) (官方)
  13. [13] Replika — homepage (官方)
  14. [14] Replika Terms of Service (last updated Mar 30, 2026) (官方)
  15. [15] Replika Privacy Policy (last updated May 27, 2026) (官方)
  16. [16] Vice — Replika brings back erotic AI roleplay for some users after outcry (Mar 27, 2023) (第三方)

我們的寫作原則:事實取自各服務自己的條款、說明中心、文件或公告,第三方來源會另外標示。每篇指南至少每 90 天重新核實一次。

Kindroid, Nomi and Replika belong to their respective owners. ShortFling is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any of them. Features, plans and policies change — check the official pages linked above before deciding.