本指南目前僅提供英文版。閱讀英文版 →

比較

NovelAI vs Sudowrite vs AI Dungeon: which fits writers of adult fiction?

Two of these are writing assistants and one is an interactive adventure game, and their rules on mature content, ownership and data differ in ways that matter if you plan to publish. Here is what each one’s own terms and help pages say.

作者:ShortFling Editorial · Editorial team · 最後核實:2026-10-08

重點摘要

  • NovelAI and Sudowrite are writing assistants for adults (both require users to be 18+); AI Dungeon is a roleplay-style text adventure open from age 13, with an 18+ confirmation for its Mature AI setting.
  • Mature content works differently in each: Sudowrite depends on which AI model you pick, AI Dungeon on your account’s AI Safety Setting, and NovelAI’s terms set an age rule rather than a theme-by-theme content list.
  • On ownership, NovelAI and Sudowrite say your writing is yours; AI Dungeon’s terms let you use your content largely as you wish but grant Latitude a licence to operate the service.
  • On training: Sudowrite says it does not train AI models on your writing; AI Dungeon’s terms say inputs and outputs may be used to improve and train its AI; NovelAI encrypts stored stories in your browser.
  • All three use paid plans; check each site for current prices.

The short answer

If you are drafting a novel and want an AI that can follow explicit or dark material, Sudowrite (with the right model selected) and NovelAI are the two built for manuscript work. If you want to play through a story turn by turn rather than produce a manuscript, AI Dungeon is the game in this group. The details below come from each service’s own terms and help pages, read in October 2026.

Weighing character-chat tools instead? Our comparison of Janitor AI, SillyTavern and NovelAI looks at the roleplay side of the same space.

NovelAI: an encrypted writing studio for adults

NovelAI offers AI story writing alongside an anime-style image generator, and describes its writing tool as an AI “that writes with you — not for you.”[3]

  • Age: its terms require users to be 18 or older.[1]
  • Mature content: the terms set the 18+ requirement but do not publish a separate rating system or theme-by-theme adult-content list.[1]
  • Ownership: NovelAI says you retain all rights and ownership of your content and that it does not claim the material you create.[1][2]
  • Data: text stories are encrypted in your browser before they are stored, so story data at rest on its servers is encrypted.[2]
  • Training: its terms note that information you voluntarily provide for model training cannot be deleted once training has started.[1]
  • Payment model: monthly subscription tiers, with one-time free trial actions for text and image generation after sign-up.[2][3]

Sudowrite: a fiction assistant with a model picker

Sudowrite presents itself as a creativity tool that is “not intended to write for you” but to help you improve and speed up your writing.[5]

  • Age: its terms require users to be at least 18.[4]
  • Mature content depends on the model you choose. Its help docs rate the content filtering of Muse, its own fiction model, as “virtually none”; the Excellent mode as permissive but likely to imply rather than describe adult scenes; and the Basic mode as strict, inheriting OpenAI’s moderation.[6]
  • Hard limits: the terms prohibit sexually explicit content featuring minors and content that sexually exploits minors.[4]
  • Ownership: Sudowrite says it claims no rights over anything you put in or anything it generates for you; its terms take only a limited licence to host and process your content to run and improve the service.[4][5][7]
  • Training: its FAQ states that it does not use your writing to train AI models.[5]
  • Payment model: subscription plans with a monthly allotment of credits; unused monthly credits expire unless your plan allows rollover, and extra credits can be bought separately. A free trial is mentioned in its FAQ.[4][5]

AI Dungeon: an interactive adventure, not a manuscript tool

AI Dungeon calls itself “a roleplay experience”: you take turns with the AI using Do, Say and Story inputs, and a See mode generates images.[11]

  • Age: users must be at least 13, but some features are restricted to people who have reached the age of majority (typically 18).[8]
  • Mature content: an account-wide AI Safety Setting has three levels — Safe, Moderate and Mature. Mature does not limit mature, violent or triggering output, and you must confirm you are 18+ to turn it on.[10]
  • Published versus private: its community guidelines say private and unlisted adventures for personal use are not moderated, while published scenarios carry ratings (Everyone, Teen, Mature, Unrated) and consensual sexual content as a primary focus is rated Unrated (18+).[9]
  • Never publishable: sexual content involving minors and non-consensual sexual content, among other categories listed in the guidelines.[9]
  • Ownership: its terms say you can use your own content “pretty much however you want,” while granting Latitude a licence to host, store and distribute it as needed to run the service; they also warn that similar outputs may be generated for other players.[8]
  • Training: the terms say Latitude may use your inputs and outputs to operate, improve and train its AI, subject to any controls it makes available.[8]
  • Payment model: free models are available, with paid subscriptions and a one-time trial period for premium features.[8][11]

Side-by-side comparison

Checked October 8, 2026 — payment model only; check each site for current prices
NovelAISudowriteAI Dungeon
What it isAI writing studio + image generatorAI fiction-writing assistantAI roleplay / text adventure
Minimum age18+18+13+ (some features 18+)
Mature content control18+ service; no published theme listDepends on the model (Muse: “virtually none” filtering)Account AI Safety Setting; Mature needs 18+ confirmation
Who owns your writingYou (no ownership claimed)You (no rights claimed)You, with a licence to Latitude to run the service
Training on your writingTerms address data you volunteer for trainingSays it does not train on your writingInputs/outputs may be used to train its AI
Privacy angleStored stories encrypted in the browserLimited licence to host and processPrivate adventures are not moderated
Payment modelSubscription, one-time free trialSubscription with monthly creditsFree models + subscription, one-time trial
Best forLong-form co-writing with privacyDrafting and revising a manuscriptPlaying through an adventure

Which one fits your project

  • You are writing a novel or novella with explicit scenes and want help with prose: Sudowrite, provided you check which model you are using, since its filtering differs by model.[6]
  • You care most about where your drafts sit: NovelAI’s browser-side encryption of stored stories is its distinguishing point.[2]
  • You want the AI to drive a story while you react, more game than manuscript: AI Dungeon, with the Mature setting enabled only if you are 18+.[10]
  • You plan to publish or sell the result: read the ownership and licence sections of whichever terms apply. NovelAI and Sudowrite disclaim ownership; AI Dungeon notes that outputs may not be unique to you.[1][5][8]

Mature settings never lift the hard lines. Sudowrite’s terms and AI Dungeon’s guidelines both prohibit sexual content involving minors, and NovelAI is an 18+ service. Keep every character an adult.

Your options on ShortFling

ShortFling is not an AI chat app or an adventure game, and it is not a like-for-like replacement for these tools. It is a fiction platform where you can also write and publish. The /write studio gives each story a chapter-by-chapter manuscript editor with an AI editor beside it. The editor answers questions, gives notes, helps set the direction of the next chapter, and has one-tap actions to expand a passage, add a transition or adjust tone. It is designed to coach rather than ghost-write whole chapters, and it replies in the language you write to it in.

You need an account and must sign a creator agreement before creating a story. AI editor use is free within a daily quota, then costs coins. Every character must be an adult, and the site asks every visitor to confirm they are 18+ before entering. Publishing submits a story for review, and it goes public once approved. Finished work appears in ShortFling Fiction, and adult readers can browse the NSFW stories zone. Vertical short dramas are listed as coming soon.

常見問題

Is NovelAI or Sudowrite better for writing adult fiction?

Both are 18+ writing assistants. Sudowrite lets you choose a model, and its own docs say its Muse model has virtually no content filtering while its Basic mode is strict. NovelAI’s main distinction is that stored stories are encrypted in your browser. Try each one’s free trial on your own manuscript before subscribing.

Does AI Dungeon allow NSFW content?

With the account-wide AI Safety Setting on Mature, the AI is not limited from generating mature content, and you must confirm you are 18+ to enable it. Published scenarios with consensual sexual content as the main focus are rated Unrated (18+), and some categories, including anything sexual involving minors, can never be published.

Do these tools train AI on my writing?

Sudowrite says it does not. AI Dungeon’s terms say inputs and outputs may be used to improve and train its AI. NovelAI’s terms address data you voluntarily provide for training, which cannot be deleted once training has started.

Who owns a story I write with these tools?

NovelAI and Sudowrite both state that they claim no ownership of what you create. AI Dungeon lets you use your own content largely as you wish but takes a licence to host and distribute it while operating the service. Read the current terms before publishing commercially.

Is ShortFling an AI writing tool like these?

Partly. ShortFling is a fiction platform, not an AI chat app or adventure game. Its /write studio includes an AI editor that gives notes and suggestions on your chapters, free within a daily quota and then paid in coins.

資料來源

  1. [1] NovelAI Terms of Service (官方)
  2. [2] NovelAI Documentation — FAQ (官方)
  3. [3] NovelAI website (官方)
  4. [4] Sudowrite Docs — Terms and Conditions (updated April 11, 2025) (官方)
  5. [5] Sudowrite — Frequently Asked Questions (官方)
  6. [6] Sudowrite Docs — Which AI model should I use? (updated January 14, 2026) (官方)
  7. [7] Sudowrite Docs — Intellectual Property and Ownership (updated January 20, 2026) (官方)
  8. [8] AI Dungeon Guidebook — Terms of Service (官方)
  9. [9] AI Dungeon Guidebook — Community Guidelines (官方)
  10. [10] AI Dungeon Guidebook — What are the AI Safety Settings? (官方)
  11. [11] AI Dungeon Guidebook — How do I play AI Dungeon? (官方)

我們的寫作原則:事實取自各服務自己的條款、說明中心、文件或公告,第三方來源會另外標示。每篇指南至少每 90 天重新核實一次。

NovelAI, Sudowrite and AI Dungeon are trademarks of their respective owners (AI Dungeon is operated by Latitude, Inc.). ShortFling is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any of them. Policies and plans change — check the official pages linked above before deciding.